Does Including an LGBTQ Subplot Increase Your Enjoyment of Movies and TV Shows?

Many argue that the inclusion of LGBTQ or gay subplots in media is a crutch to political correctness. While for some viewers, such content might not be necessary or even off-putting, others find it refreshing to see more realistic and normalized representations of LGBTQ characters and relationships.

Authenticity and Quality Matter

The enjoyment of such content depends largely on how well it fits into the narrative. If the addition is a contrived part of the story, full of clichés and poorly written, it is unlikely to boost the viewer's enjoyment. However, when the LGBTQ content is well-written and well-integrated into the plot, it can significantly enhance the viewing experience.

Subtle Representation

Subtle representation, such as a character mentioning their spouse or partner in passing, can also have a positive impact. This does not necessarily require a fully developed subplot. For example, a line like 'my husband' or 'my wife' can make a viewer feel more represented and understood. It signals that producers and writers noticed and cared to include a diverse range of characters.

Escaping Stereotypes and Tokenism

There is still a tendency for LGBTQ characters to be used purely for reactionary drama or coming-out stories, rather than fully realized, everyday characters. This includes films and television series focusing on LGBTQ relationships as a central theme, such as 'Boy Erased' or 'Prayers for Bobby', which often serve as a backdrop for other narratives. In many of these stories, LGBTQ characters are not given a chance to be the main characters or to explore other facets of their lives.

A Case in Point: 'The Family Stone'

In 'The Family Stone', the inclusion of a gay son serves more as a plot device than as a natural part of the family dynamic. The character is only included to create friction and drama within the family, as the mother, Diane Keaton, tries to teach Sarah Jessica Parker a lesson about accepting difference. This approach feels tokenistic and detracts from the true experience of being a LGBTQ individual in a family setting. It is a missed opportunity to show the everyday, non-dramatic aspects of LGBTQ life.

Visibility and Normalization

The goal should be to see LGBTQ characters in a wide range of roles and stories, not just those driven by their sexuality. Characters should be able to be bomb disposal experts, serial killers, or protagonists in a variety of thrilling scenarios without being defined by their sexual orientation. For example, 'Source Code' offers a single instance where a gay character could have been included without altering the plot significantly. Such inclusive representation would help normalize LGBTQ experiences and challenge the stereotypes.

Evolution in Media Representation

Currently, we are still largely in the domain of LGBTQ characters being seen primarily in coming-out or dysfunctional family dramas. However, as more producers and writers move away from these tropes and create authentic, everyday portrayals, we can begin to see a shift in how LGBTQ characters are represented. As this shift occurs, we should embrace and celebrate it, recognizing that diversity in stories enriches and enhances the media ecosystem.

Ultimately, the inclusion of LGBTQ subplots can significantly enhance the enjoyment of movies and TV shows provided that the representation is authentic, well-integrated, and not used as a mere plot device. As media continues to evolve and become more inclusive, we can look forward to a richer and more diverse range of stories and characters.