Do Inmates in Jails and Prisons Watch TV Cop Shows?

In the intricate tapestry of prison life, one common and intriguing phenomenon is the brand of entertainment provided by television cop shows and crime dramas. From Law Order to Better Call Saul, many inmates find solace, escapism, and sometimes a mirror to their own realities in these popular TV formats. In this article, we explore the varying attitudes of inmates towards these shows and how they reflect their broader experiences and perspectives on justice and law enforcement.

Entertainment and Escapism

For many inmates, watching TV is a way to escape the monotony and harsh realities of incarceration. Cop shows, with their high-stakes narrative and dramatic flair, provide a stark contrast to the oppressive environment of jails and prisons. Even when the content resonates with their own experiences, it can offer a temporary diversion. This form of escapism allows them to momentarily forget about daily anxieties and grievances.

Identification with Characters

A significant number of inmates, particularly those who feel misunderstood or wronged by the justice system, can identify with the characters, especially the suspects. This identification often leads to rooting for the oft-maligned figures on screen, creating a sense of camaraderie. Some see their struggles in the characters and may find a shadow of hope in their eventual outcomes. However, it is not uncommon for such identification to spill over into discussions and even debates among inmates about the accuracy and fairness of the portrayed scenarios.

Critical Viewing and Discussions

Not all inmates approach these shows with blind optimism or disinterest. Some watch with a critical eye, dissecting the portrayal of crime and justice. They analyze how these shows depict reality and often engage in discussions with fellow inmates about these portrayals. These conversations can be both enlightening and controversial, as they reveal deep-seated views on the criminal justice system, its fairness, and its fallacies.

Varied Reactions and Realities

The reactions to cop shows among inmates are multifaceted and often nuanced. Some may relish in the thrill of the chase and root for the protagonists, while others may sympathize with the suspects or (ironically) critique the justice system. This diversity in reactions underscores the wide range of personal experiences and perspectives that exist within the prison walls. Each inmate brings to the table a unique set of baggage and beliefs, which influences how they interpret and engage with these television shows.

Blue Lights in Prison Culture

A particularly fascinating anecdote comes from Hungarian prisons, where the inmate population collectively holds breath when the weekly program titled “Blue Lights” (Kék fény) begins. This dry, official report offers a stark contrast to the dramatic and melodramatic nature of cop shows. Unlike in other prisons, inmates here don't typically root for the bad guys. They, like many, maintain a clear sense of right and wrong, even if they have made their own unlawful choices. These reports provide a sobering look at real-life policing, fostering a mix of education and entertainment.

The watching of "Blue Lights" and other similarly unglamorous depictions of justice may also serve as a form of catharsis. It allows inmates to reflect on their own situations and the harsh realities of the justice system. It can be a sobering reminder of the consequences of their actions but also a glimpse of the humanity that can be preserved even in the direst of circumstances.

In essence, the viewing of cop shows and crime dramas in prisons serves as a complex intersection of entertainment, education, and reflection. It offers a window into the psyche of inmates and their broader perspectives on justice, law enforcement, and the human condition.

Conclusion

Yes, many inmates do watch cop shows and crime dramas. Their varied reactions to these shows reflect their complex lived experiences and a wide array of perspectives on justice and law enforcement. By engaging with these television formats, inmates are likely seeking both solace and a means to process their own realities. This cultural phenomenon is not just a distraction from the hardships of prison life but also a lens through which broader societal issues and personal struggles are examined and discussed.