Is Silly Putty a Viable Fishing Lure?
When it comes to angling and trying out new techniques, some unconventional ideas pop up. One such item you might have mentioned in a casual conversation is silly putty. But is it actually a viable option as a fishing lure? Let's take a closer look at why this assumption is likely misguided.
Understanding Silly Putty
Silly putty is a non-Newtonian polymer that has the ability to stretch and bounce like a rubber ball while also flowing like water. Its unique properties and soft, elastic consistency make it a favorite in the hands of children around the world. With a history dating back to the 1940s, silly putty has remained relevant for decades, captivating the curiosity of many with its inquisitive and playful nature. However, in the realm of fishing, its characteristics are far less favorable.
The Challenges of Using Silly Putty as a Lure
When considering the use of silly putty as a fishing lure, there are several practical and physical challenges to address. Firstly, the elasticity and hardness of the material pose significant obstacles. Imagine trying to affix a hook to one end of a substance that can both deform and return to its original shape. This would not provide a secure and reliable structure for attaching a fishing line or lure. Furthermore, the credibility of the lure is questionable. In nature, fish are accustomed to attacking and swallowing live or moving prey. A floating, non-food-like object like silly putty would likely trigger suspicion or simply pass through the fish's mouth, leading to no catch at all. The traditional lures, on the other hand, are designed to mimic the appearance and movements of their intended targets, leading to higher chances of success.
The Reality of Fishing Lures
Fishing lures are carefully crafted to address the specific needs of anglers and to effectively mimic the behavior of fish's natural food sources. The primary purpose is to attract fish and entice them to strike. Here are a few critical factors to consider:
Material Durability
Thick and rugged materials are essential for lures. They need to withstand the force of the fish and hold up over time. Silly putty's brittle and pliable nature makes it prone to breaking, especially under the strain of a strong fish. Traditional lures like weighted dart lures, wood plastics, and rubber imitation baits are specifically designed for durability and can endure the rigors of angling.
Attractiveness and Mimicry
The visual and tactile appeal of a lure is crucial. Fish are attracted to movement, colors, and shapes that mimic their natural prey. Lures with mimetic designs like swimbaits, spinners, and spoons are specifically created to replicate the behavior of fish food. Silly putty, with its unpredictable shape and lack of any actual resemblance to a fish's natural diet, would not perform these functions effectively.
Comfort and Safety for Anglers
A fishing lure also needs to be manageable and safe for the angler. If a lure is too fragile, it can break easily, causing irritation or injury. Silly putty's danger of rupturing can lead to messy hands and potential cuts or abrasions for the user. High-quality lures are made with the safety and comfort of anglers in mind, ensuring a secure and pleasant fishing experience.
Conclusion
In summary, while the idea of using silly putty as a fishing lure sounds novel and perhaps even amusing, it is not backed by functional or practical considerations. The inherent properties of silly putty do not align with the requirements of a successful fishing lure. Mimicry, durability, and safety are critical components that traditional fishing lures excel in, whereas silly putty lacks in these key areas. For those looking to improve their fishing skills, it's more productive to explore the vast array of scientifically and functionally designed lures that have been developed through extensive research and testing. Both the angler and the fish deserve the best experience possible, and that means using the right tools for the job.