Who Do You Think Was the Bigger Global Star, Jerry Lewis or Dean Martin?

The relationship between comedy legends Jerry Lewis and Dean Martin was a complex one, filled with both collaboration and competition. Both were household names, but who truly stood above the other in the grand scheme of entertainment history? Let's delve deeper into the dynamics that shaped their careers and fame.

Arthur Marx’s Perspective: “Everybody Loves Somebody Sometimes Especially Himself”

Arthur Marx's book Everybody Loves Somebody Sometime Especially Himself offers a unique insight into the dynamics that existed between Lewis and Martin. Marx, a noted Broadway producer, provides a candid look at how the two men navigated their relationship and career.

Jerry's Dominance in Their Career: Dean Martin was often frustrated by Jerry Lewis's all-encompassing presence in their career. Martin envisioned a life where he performed and then retired to his favorite pastime—playing golf. However, Lewis, with his energetic work ethic, was more of a presence on stage and found it hard to let go. Personal Differences: Where Lewis was outgoing and a hard worker, Martin was a very private individual. This contrast created friction, especially when Lewis would want to take over writing and directing duties, while Martin excelled in ad-libbed humor, causing physical and emotional stress to Lewis. The Painful Divorce: The closeness of their relationship eventually turned into a painful divorce. Both men had their own group of sycophants who believed they could survive without each other, often contributing to the tension. Equally Famous: By the end of their careers, both were equally famous. While Martin gained significant success in television and his Ratpack era, Lewis's early film success and his significant draw at Las Vegas kept him in the spotlight.

Dean Martin: A Global Superstar

Dean Martin, often hailed as the driving force behind their success, was more popular and well-liked on an international scale. His movie stardom and music career, including his legendary Ratpack days, saw him become a true international icon. His ability to transition effortlessly between dramatic roles and lighthearted commercials solidified his status as a true legend.

Jerry Lewis: An Iconic Figure in the Spotlight

Jerry Lewis, with his early film success and his lucrative partnership, has become a cultural icon. His grossly successful early films made a fortune for him and Paramount, and he was a constant draw at Las Vegas.

Conclusion: A Slight Edge to Dean Martin

While Jerry Lewis seemed to exude larger-than-life qualities, each man brought his own unique strengths and contributed to the cultural fabric of Hollywood. However, considering the international success, broader appeal, and lasting impact on popular culture, I would have to give the edge, albeit a thin one, to Dean Martin.

Both Jerry Lewis and Dean Martin remain idols for many, and the complex relationship between them continues to fascinate historians, biographers, and fans alike. Despite their differences, they both authored significant chapters in the rich history of entertainment.