The Motivation Behind F?anor’s Creation of the Silmarils

F?anor, the greatest of the Noldorin Silvans, was driven by a deeper motivation than mere aesthetics when he crafted the Silmarils. His quest for artistry and personal glory, intertwined with the looming danger posed by Melkor, led to one of the most pivotal moments in the legendarium of Middle-earth.

Artistic Motivation and Joy of Creation

..

His only motivation was to make something marvellous and beautiful both for its own sake and also for his own agrandissement. He hoped that people would speak of his genius as a master craftsman. F?anor made the Silmarils well before Melkor was released from captivity, and they were the peak of elvish creation. The joy and thrill of creating amazing artefacts were at the core of his motivation. His skill was so honed that he could even wear the Silmarils to parties and feasts, not just as a symbol of pride but also to captivate the admiration of his peers.

Driven to Create

..

Driven by his relentless creativity, F?anor's mind and hands were hardly ever at rest. He was constantly dreaming up new ideas and setting them to work, making his dreams a reality. The creation of the Silmarils was the culmination of a life dedicated to mastering his art. Despite the knowledge that the very objects he painstakingly crafted would eventually be stolen by Melkor, F?anor’s focus remained on the beauty and craftsmanship of the Silmarils. This constant drive and passion for creation were his greatest virtues, as well as his ultimate downfall. The Silmarils, known for their brilliance, were a testament to F?anor’s unparalleled talent.

Sadly, the Humble Beginnings Led to Tragic Endings

..

Unfortunately, the humble beginnings Sauron attributes to F?anor did not end well. The Silmarils were created before Melkor's release, and their exquisite beauty was his greatest accomplishment. Few in Aman knew that Melkor was planning to destroy the Two Trees, Telperion and Laurelin. These trees would eventually be turned into the silmarils, making them incredibly valuable despite their immense beauty. F?anor’s arrogance and the envy he harbored were exacerbated by a warning from Galadriel. Her rejection of his request for a strand of her hair to turn into a gem further fueled his resentment and eventual descent into shadows.

Concluding Thoughts

..

In summary, F?anor’s motivation for creating the Silmarils stemmed from a deep-seated passion for craftsmanship and a desire for recognition. Although his creations were magnificent, his obsession with them and the subsequent betrayal by Melkor would lead to lasting consequences. The story of the Silmarils serves as a cautionary tale about the perils of pride and the dangers of obsessive creation. In the end, the magnificence of the Silmarils was overshadowed by the tragic events that followed.

Keywords: F?anor, Silmarils, Melkor, Noldor