The Quest for Renewal: Rey Skywalker and the Potential Revival of the Jedi Order

The much-anticipated Rey Skywalker standalone film has stirred speculation about the possible revival of the Jedi Order. While the film's production is uncertain, fans have continued to debate the implications of Rey's potential journey.

Is the Film Likely to Be Made?

Assuming the film actually gets made… it remains a significant question mark. Numerous developmental and financial challenges have led to the cancellation or limbo of many Star Wars projects. Key points to consider include:

The selected director has almost no experience in narrative filmmaking, with a background primarily in documentary. Revisions to the screenplay have been numerous, with each draft facing cancellation. Declining interest in the franchise is evident through merchandise sales and ratings.

Given these factors, it’s highly improbable that the film will see the light of day.

The Rationale Behind Rey's Journey

Should the film ever be produced, it is likely to explore complex themes related to Rey's struggle to recreate the Jedi Order. Set 15 years after The Rise of Skywalker, the narrative might focus on Rey's journey to understand the political and ethical challenges that come with reinstating the Sith-executed Jedi Order.

Rey will likely confront the consequences of Jedi secrecy, particularly in terms of how their actions influenced the rise of the Sith and the subsequent rule by the Empire and the First Order. The film may delve into the idea that if the Jedi had been more transparent, the Sith could have been exposed and Palpatine might not have risen to power.

Challenges and Antagonism

Furthermore, rumors suggest that Rey might face a "Starkiller"-type adversary, adding tension and conflict to her mission. This antagonist could represent a new threat that challenges Rey's ability to establish the Jedi Order successfully.

Is a New Jedi Order Feasible?

The notion of a new Jedi Order raises significant doubts. The debacles in past iterations of the Jedi Order, such as the tragic events of the Skywalker Saga, offer a bleak perspective on the potential for such a revival:

Anakin Skywalker, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Leia Organa, and Luke Skywalker all experienced tragic lives marred by the war and destruction. The Jedi Order played a part in many of the galaxy's conflicts. Individuals like Rey, who faced severe hardship, may question the merit of recreating a system that has led to repeated trauma and conflict.

Considering the galaxy's history, Rey’s predicament suggests that a new order might not bring peace. Many argue that if the Jedi Order were abolished, the galaxy would have avoided much of its suffering. Opponents of a new Jedi Order note that Rey, having just survived traumatic experiences, may not wish to perpetuate a cycle of conflict.

The "Team Luke" Perspective

Some fans maintain that Luke Skywalker's efforts, though flawed, laid the groundwork for a more balanced leadership structure. The argument for Luke centers on the idea that his leadership, while impacted by darkness, provided a template for handling power responsibly and constructively.

Ultimately, the likelihood of Rey’s journey leading to a successful Jedi Order remains speculative. The complexities of the Star Wars universe and the potential for another ripple effect suggest that the revival of the Jedi might not be the simple, utopian answer it appears to some.