Why People Ask about States Instead of Simply 'Where'?

Surely, why do people ask such a ridiculous question such as 'What state are you from’?

Is it because they think you come from a country that has states, like the United States? In places like South Africa, where provinces are the administrative divisions, you would never hear a similar query.

Perhaps, it is due to cultural sensitivity. It is crucial to be cautious about offending someone, especially when they have parents who emigrated from another country. For example, in the United States, asking straightforward questions like, 'Where are you from,' might carry an unforeseen implication that the person does not belong there or is not welcome.

Reasons for Asking 'What State Are You From' Instead of 'Where'

Here are a few reasons why people in the United States might ask, 'What state are you from' instead of a simpler 'Where' question:

1. Politeness and Cultural Sensitivity

Americans are often a bit more direct and straightforward. However, this doesn't mean that everyone is quick to offend. For many, the initial question, 'Where are you from,' might imply a sense of suspicion or even a xenophobic undertone. People born in the U.S. but with parents from another country might prefer the phrase, 'What state are you from.' This is a gentler way to start a conversation and avoid potential misunderstandings or rudeness.

2. Geographic Clarity and Relevance

Asking about states can be more meaningful and relevant than asking about towns. For instance, if someone says, 'I’m from California,' this gives a clearer geographical context compared to 'I’m from Reedley' or 'I’m from Yorba Linda.' People generally understand and are familiar with states, especially when discussing issues related to local administration, law, or education.

3. Context-Specific Reasons

There are several specific contexts where the state of origin is more important than the town. For example:

University Admissions and Tuition

At distinguished state-supported institutions like the University of Michigan, University of Virginia, or one of the ten campuses of the University of California, the state of origin can significantly impact admission standards and tuition requirements for out-of-state students. This distinction is important for universities to consider, as it affects the diversity of their student body and the financial resources they need to maintain their programs.

Professional Licensing and Regulation

At professional conferences, the states from which people come can determine licensing requirements and the specific issues they face. For instance, lawyers practicing in the same specialty but in different states may face different legal challenges and regulations. This can be crucial for professionals to understand when forming networks or seeking collaboration.

In conclusion, while the question 'Where are you from' may seem simpler and more direct, the nuances in the phrase 'What state are you from' reflect cultural sensitivity, geographic clarity, and context-specific reasons that make it an often preferred choice. Understanding these subtleties can help improve intercultural communication and foster a more inclusive environment.